About us What we do Associations Membership Product Finder Exhibitions Resource hub News & Publications Automate BEST Contact us
background image
background image
background image
background image
background image
background image
background image
background image
background image
background image
arrow back
Become a member arrow right
Stay up to date

Please provide a valid email address

Please select one or more contact preferences

Sign up

The NEET crisis is a growth crisis: our response to the Milburn report

Back to News & Publications

The NEET crisis is a growth crisis: our response to the Milburn report

18 November 2026

Alan Milburn's final report on young people not in education, employment or training (NEET) was published on 18 November 2026. Our Policy Director, Peter Williamson, explains why industry has a big part to play in fixing the problem.

You might not expect someone from the automation industry to be among the loudest voices on youth unemployment and skills. But on the factory floor the reality is this: our members are desperately short of skilled people, and nearly one million young people are being left without a clear route into work.

Alan Milburn's final report is right to call for a whole-system reset, and those of us in industry have known for a long time that one is needed. The NEET crisis is not just a social challenge. It is a growth challenge. And young people deserve better.

Talented young people are being left behind

As Policy Director for Automate UK, I've seen that business wants to be part of the solution. Members consistently tell me they are struggling to recruit people with the right skills. At the same time, talented young people can't find meaningful routes into employment.

There are many reasons for this. One we see time and again is that young people with the right skills, the right way of thinking and the right attitude may lack the academic ability to pass exams in subjects they won't need for a career in manufacturing.

This isn't about saying one subject matters more than another, or that we should drop parts of the curriculum. It's about being adaptable, so that young people with bright futures can succeed through an educational pathway that sets them up to pass, not fail.

That is why I welcome the report's call for technical education to sit on an equal footing with academic education. This includes the new Vocational GCSEs and technical pathways from age 14, and a new ready-for-work standard that would judge schools on where their students end up, not just on exam results. As the report makes clear, the aim is to broaden our definition of educational success rather than dilute it.

Across manufacturing, engineering, logistics and technology, employers are competing for a limited pool of talent while capable young people are shut out. With growth rightly at the top of the Government's agenda, this is a contradiction we can no longer afford to ignore.

Young people want to work

Milburn rightly challenges the assumption that this is simply about young people not wanting to work. The overwhelming majority do. The report's own research finds that more than seven in ten young people who are NEET want to be in work, education or training.

The problem is that moving from education into employment is getting harder. Entry-level jobs are harder to get, apprenticeships have declined, and many young people are stuck between education, training and work with no clear way forward. Six in ten young people who are NEET have never had a job. Among those who want to work, the biggest barrier they cite is a lack of experience, which is exactly what employers are best placed to provide.

"The NEET crisis is not just a social challenge. It is a growth challenge."

Peter Williamson, Policy Director, Automate UK

Employers must be part of the solution

Last year, Automate BEST, the charity we fund, launched its Apprenticeship Cluster programme. It brings businesses, educators and apprentices together to create stronger pathways into manufacturing careers. Businesses work in groups rather than in isolation, sharing expertise, broadening apprentices' experience and making it less risky for employers to invest in future skills.

So far, the charity has helped over 300 apprentices into full-time roles, with well over 10% of them benefiting from the Cluster experience. This is one practical example of what can happen when industry takes ownership of the skills challenge rather than waiting for government to solve it alone.

It is also the direction the report points in. Apprenticeships are the largest education and skills priority in the review, which aims to double the number of young people completing one over the next decade. That means annual under-25 starts rising towards 270,000 by 2036, plus an initial 25,000 pre-apprenticeship places.

Good initiatives can't stay isolated

But successful initiatives can't remain isolated examples, and they can't solve the crisis alone. If we are serious about tackling youth inactivity, we need a system that brings government, employers and business-led initiatives like the Apprenticeship Cluster together. That system should learn from what works, then share it, replicate it and reward it.

The report's proposals go a long way towards this:

  • A permanent Youth Opportunity Service in every part of England, acting as a single front door for young people and employers alike.
  • First Chance, an employer-led movement setting out what business can contribute: more first jobs, more youth apprenticeships and much wider access to meaningful work experience.
  • Mayors and strategic authorities taking responsibility for the participation system for 16 to 24-year-olds, giving local employers a clear route in.

Young people need clearer routes into sectors that are growing and recruiting. Businesses need confidence that their innovations and interventions will be recognised.

Hiring young people must feel less risky

The report also highlights something my members often raise with me. Taking on young people can feel increasingly risky, particularly for small and medium-sized businesses. SMEs are the backbone of our economy, but most operate with limited resources, complex regulations and little room for error. If we want more employers to create opportunities for young people, we need a system that helps de-risk those decisions.

The final report is concrete on this. It proposes:

  • a £3,000 payment to employers who take on a young person who has been NEET for six months
  • further £2,000 premiums for young people facing greater barriers and for businesses with fewer than 50 employees
  • a £2,500 payment for creating an apprenticeship, extended to levy payers

Together, the package would be worth around £1.1 billion a year and could help create 170,000 additional jobs and apprenticeships. The report also proposes a statutory Youth Opportunity Test, so that the impact of major tax, spending and regulatory decisions on young people is considered before they are made. And it calls for the effect on youth employment to be a primary consideration when the new Guaranteed Hours legislation is finalised.

A new bargain between employers and government

Employers also need more flexibility through the Growth and Skills Levy. The report proposes that the levy should fully fund apprenticeships for under-25s by ending the Treasury topslice. It also supports shorter, more targeted training and making it easier for businesses to invest in upskilling and reskilling.

Participation can't be siloed. We can't rely only on schools and colleges, and we can't rely only on business. Employers want to play their part, but they need the right support and incentives, and confidence that the State will match their efforts.

The report frames this as a new bargain: employers create more first chances and, in return, government makes hiring young people easier, cheaper and less risky. We will want to see the detail on how adult upskilling and reskilling will stay supported while government funding for apprentices aged 25 and over is reduced. That support matters more than ever as businesses adopt automation.

Technology creates opportunity, but young people aren't convinced

Automation, robotics and digital technologies are already changing workplaces across the UK. Contrary to old perceptions, they don't remove opportunity. They create demand for new technical, engineering and digital skills.

Young people are not yet convinced. The Youth Voice Census cited in the report found that 69% have used AI or machine-learning tools, yet 55% say technological change makes them uncertain about the future and only 19% believe it will create more opportunities.

Industry has a responsibility to show them otherwise. The report is right that the answer is not to protect particular occupations, but to give young people the adaptability to thrive as work changes, and to make sure more of them can reach those opportunities.

Productivity and participation go hand in hand

The UK's productivity challenge and its youth participation challenge are two sides of the same coin. The report estimates that higher youth participation could add around 0.4% to GDP every year by 2036. The NEET crisis already costs the country around £125 billion a year, including almost £22 billion in fiscal costs.

If we are serious about growth, competitiveness and opportunity in every part of the country, we must do more to help young people move from education into work.

Time to act

Alan Milburn's final report must be a wake-up call. We cannot keep accepting a situation where nearly one million young people are left on the sidelines while employers struggle to fill vacancies and grow.

The report sets out a ten-year plan to bring the NEET rate down to just over 5% by 2036. It starts with £500 million of initial investment in 2027/28 and calls for the 2027 spending review to prioritise the funding the programme needs.

Government now has to act on it, and industry must be ready to step up alongside. The talent is there. The ambition is there. Our task now is to build a system that brings them together.

Read the full report: From a welfare state to a working state: a new settlement for the next generation (GOV.UK)

Meet your Automate AI assistant.

I can help you find information about:

  • Products
  • Services
  • Trainings
  • Product features
  • Product demos
  • Useful product/service related information

If you prefer direct assistance from one of our representatives, please get in touch via the channels below:

{{ message.query }}

Or take a look at our most searched topics...